
On June 21st, the EPA proposed that it was time to strengthen the nation's air quality standards for ground-level ozone, revising the standards set in 1997. According to the EPA, the new proposal is based on the most recent scientific evidence available about the health effects of ozone, which is the primary component of smog."Advances in science are leading to cleaner skies and healthier lives," said EPA Administrator Stephen L. Johnson. "America's science is progressing and our air quality is improving. By strengthening the ozone standard, EPA is keeping our clean air momentum moving into the future. I have concluded the current standard is insufficient to protect public health."
But environmentalists and scientific experts say the proposed regulations are not enough and fall short of standards recommend by the EPA’s own Clean Air Scientific Advisory Committee (CASAC). According to scientific documents provided to the EPA, lowering emissions standards to 0.064 parts per million rather than EPA’s proposed 0.07-0.075 ppm, would decrease ozone-related deaths by a possible 75 percent. The current regulatory level is .08 ppm.
“The law says use the science, the science says lower the standard to safe levels,” commented Francesco Grifo, director of the Scientific Integrity Program for the Union of Concerned Scientists. “In disregarding its own scientists’ analysis, the EPA is risking the health of millions of Americans.”
Ozone is a health concern for individuals with asthma or other lung diseases, as well as those who spend a lot of time outside, such as children. Ozone exposure can aggravate asthma and increase susceptibility to respiratory infections. Environmentalists believe the new proposed standard is not enough to protect the public’s health, with the higher regulation level being the result of pressure from industrial concerns and the current White House administration.
“The science is clear,” said David H. Ingbar MD, president of the American Thoracic Society, “ozone pollution is causing unnecessary, illnesses and death in America. The proposed EPA standards fall short of providing the protection needed to keep Americans safe from ozone air pollution.” Dr. Ingbar also commented that the proposed standards are “unhealthy for America’s kids, unhealthy for America’s seniors, and unhealthy for America.”
However, the National Center for Policy Analysis’ E-Team, a group of exports who offer analysis based on the concept that science, the environment and the economy should form government policies, issued another perspective to the proposed standards. They stated that reducing smog emissions standards from the current level to the level suggested by the EPA, is virtually impossible, according to Joel Schwarz, an adjunct scholar with the NCPA E-Team. Schwarz continued that even if the proposed reduction were possible, it would do nothing to improve American’s overall health. He continued “These new proposed standards would turn most of the nation into a Clean Air Act ‘non-attainment area.”
Ground-level ozone is not emitted directly into the air, but is created through a reaction of nitrogen oxides (NOx) and volatile organic compound (VOC) emissions in the presence of sunlight. Emissions from industrial facilities, electric utilities, on- and off-road vehicles, gasoline vapors, and chemical solvents are the major man-made sources of NOx and VOCs - ozone precursors.
The EPA says that the United States has made significant progress reducing ground-level ozone in the past quarter century. Since 1980, ozone levels have dropped 21 percent nationwide. Currently 104 US counties are not in compliance with today’s ozone levels. Based on the EPA’s new data and questionable proposed standard, 533 US counties would not be in compliance. Depending on the seriousness of a county’s ozone problems, they would need to comply with the new measures as soon as 2013, with possibly extensions to 2030.
The estimated health benefits of meeting a range of alternative ozone standards based on published scientific studies and the opinion of outside experts will be detailed in a Regulatory Impact Analysis issued by the EPA to be released this summer. Final adoption of the proposed regulations would go into effect by March 12, 2008, after public comment has been heard for 90 days prior to this date.
See the Source:EPA's proposal to strengthen standards for ground-level ozone
Union of Concerned Scientists
NewsWise NCPA E-Team Find out:How to lower NOx emissions for lean burn engines and gas turbines using selective catalytic reduction.
clean air
NOx emissionsLabels: EPA, ground-level ozone, NOx, NOx emissions, reduce NOx, smog-forming pollutants